Friday, April 6, 2012

Rumplestiltskin/Mr. Gold

The name of this fairytale character translates “little rattle stilt” and refers to a poltergeist.  A poltergeist is a psychic content that “rattles and clanks” and causes mischief.  This slippery character is always spinning some intrigue, some malevolent plot to ensnare the woman — or the anima in a man, keeping her captive and the man immature.

Like all archetypal dynamisms of the unconscious psyche, Rumplestiltskin reveals different facets of the unconscious that vary depending upon the viewpoint of consciousness.  One can turn the symbols of the unconscious around to observe them from multiple angles — like looking into a crystal.  He is this — and this — and that — and that.  He cannot quite be pinned down.  And it is vital to the totality of the psyche that this aspect will always be rather a “slippery” character.  This ambivalence of this psychic content is described as gold (“Mr. Gold” in the TV series “Once Upon a Time”).  The fact that the ego cannot pin it down, cannot have the final word — therein lies the gold, the highest value for consciousness, for the ego is forced into humility, forced to develop a more comprehensive personality, forced to admit of an alternative viewpoint that would modify the hegemony of the ego.

The tale of Rumplestiltskin hinges upon the magical power of naming.  In primal cultures as well as in myths, legends, fairytales, and even in the Bible, knowing the name of the vengeful deity robs the deity of some of its destructive power.  The act of naming carries with it enormous value, for to name something confers power over the unconscious psychic content.  However limited the ego’s “power-over” is, that bit of human consciousness limits the field of operation of the unconscious content’s destructive activity.  The unconscious content cannot, then, inveigle itself into every nook and cranny and take over the personality.  Naming limits the damage that the psychic content can do and limits the havoc it can wreak on consciousness.  But the ego’s power is only marginal, only relative.  In the meeting between the unconscious and the ego, consciousness is by far the weaker entity.

My one cautionary note regarding “Once Upon a Time” is this:  that due to the profit motive of broadcasting companies, producers and directors of marketing, there is a contamination and a manipulation of the archetypal material by the needs of marketing and profitability.  In such a case, such a manipulative power attitude towards the unconscious would only result in constellating the Trickster.  In such a case, one will be “caught by the beard” — like certain dwarves in fairytales.  If one is too blithe, too arrogant, too power-oriented in relation to the unconscious a balancing power attitude is set up in the unconscious.  The minute one thinks “I’ve got the answer!” one hasn’t.  The moment one supposes to have boxed things up tidily, the unconscious will not stand for it, and the ego will be duped.  The moment that producers and marketers of the TV show “Once Upon a Time” try to make the show dance to their profit advantage or power-grabbing-ratings agendas, the show will become tainted.


Rumplestiltskin of the fairytale is a disagreeable dwarf.  Most dwarves in fairytales are positive figures and highly creative and skilled craftsmen, but Mr. Gold/Rumplestiltskin is the devil’s advocate.  He says, “I am difficult to love.”  He represents the woman’s “difficult”, destructive animus which, if it could become conscious, would produce the gold of creativity for the woman.  Left unconscious however, the animus becomes “small”, irritable, ungrateful, and power-driven.  Demanding and never satisfied, the dwarf represents that extremely annoying negative animus that sometimes shows itself in a woman’s personality.  The irritable animus loses its sense of proportion and entangles the woman in small-minded, idiotic, opinionated arguments and discussions.  When a woman’s personality lacks inner firmness, due probably to some lack of nurturance early on, she identifies with a too yielding, too compliant femininity as a defense.  Therefore, this one-sided, overly-sweet quality of her personality causes the unconscious to throw up this compensatory figure of the dwarf who is completely egotistical and nasty.  This figure has to come up first however in a woman’s psychological life before she can make her way to the positive, resourceful, aspect of the helpful animus that will be represented in the figure of a prince or a helpful hunter.  In the dialectic balancing act of unconscious dynamisms, the opposite attitude must first be developed as compensation before a middle, more human ground can be established that is neither too sweet nor too irritable, neither overly compliant nor power-driven.  The woman must suffer the ignominy of her “dwarfishness”; she must suffer this “disagreeable opposite” within herself before she can make her way to a more developed, more balanced personality.

Mr. Gold/Rumplestiltskin is also the devil’s advocate.  He is the shadow trickster, the Mephistophelean archetype of choice, that causes all the storm and fury and the conflict between Mary Margaret Blanchard and Regina who represent opposite polarities of the feminine (the anima) in a man.  The battleground is also within the woman, Emma Swan, who represents the attitude of female consciousness.  Mr. Gold is the psychic content that is forever spinning out some “deal” with consciousness.  The unconscious dynamism “wants” to become conscious and therefore it “needs” and seeks out the ego’s participation and engagement.  Thus, Mr. Gold is the pawn dealer who, like Rumplestiltskin in the fairytale, would trick the woman, steal her valuables until she has nothing left to offer except to pawn her future child, who represents the new consciousness waiting to be born.  In the fairytale of Rumplestiltskin, the girl is given three days to guess his name in order to ransom her own child.  In that tale, it is because the king was greedy and did not live up to his part of the bargain that the girl (the anima) was imprisoned by dominant consciousness.  The creative aspect of the feminine, the dwarf, Rumplestiltskin, comes into the story at that moment.

Dwarves represent the creative guardians of the treasures of darkness in caves, and underground caverns (i.e., in the womb of the mother, i.e., the feminine, i.e., the unconscious).  They represent impulses of pure nature, sometimes good, sometimes evil.  Rumplestiltskin has the ability to change something quite common, dross and ordinary (hay, in this instance) into gold — something which has the highest value.  In mythology, filth and excrement frequently have a correspondence with something of the highest value, gold.  This means that something that is consider filth and rejected by consciousness (the ego) is the very thing that can bring the highest value into the personality.

Mr. Gold/Rumplestiltskin represents the symbol-making, transcendent function of the psyche that comes and goes as it will (trickster like).  We are symbol-using, symbol-needing creatures.  These symbols that are appearing in current cultural manifestations of the dominant collective are replete with the symbols we need for developing greater consciousness.  These stories tell us that it is through the anima through the feminine that new consciousness comes to the man and the dominant collective.

Sources:  Marie Louise von Franz, "The Feminine in Fairytales" and "Shadow and Evil in Fairytales"; and Carl Jung, "Symbols of Transformation".

Labels: ,

Tuesday, January 31, 2012

"Once Upon a Time" — a Fairytale to Bring us to Ourselves


Post #2 on January 31, 2011:  There is a reason that the new TV series “Once Upon a Time” is immensely popular.  The show’s popularity is not just a result of clever marketing or the fact that it is exceptionally well done and visually stunning.  We are fascinated by it because there is, collectively as a society and as individuals, a psychological “hook” that snags us.  We are fascinated by it because it is us.  It shows us an image of our own unconscious dynamics.  More than that though, it shows us an image of a psychological process/struggle that is going on not just within individuals but within the collective unconscious.  It is fascinating stuff, and I would not miss a single episode except under great duress.  For me, this show is one of the more hopeful signs of our collective situation, because it is about the business of soul that has been lost in our patriarchal culture.  The business of soul is the business of the feminine — whether of the feminine ego personality or of the development of the anima, the feminine within a man.

“Once Upon a Time” has the potential to make us aware of the enormous split in Western culture.  Whenever there is too much one-sidedness, the psyche (collective or individual) seeks to balance itself.  The worse the imbalance towards one pole becomes, the stronger the reaction will be from the side of the unconscious in an attempt to balance the psyche.  We need to rediscover the immense psychological value of fairy tales, especially the fairy tales of our current era, which are absolutely chock full of witches, dragons and devouring dominatrix figures.  In the imaginative creations of broadcast and cinematic media we see snapshots of the collective unconscious. These modern fairy tales are full of clues about where consciousness is deficient, and the direction where the unconscious archetypal forces are pressing us to go.

Becoming aware of the split in the psyche is the sine qua non, the prerequisite for awakening consciousness and the development of a new world order.  We are made aware of the split-ness of our situation by the appearance of the image of twins, one good, one evil.  (See Post #1 of this date.)  In “Once Upon a Time,” the split is in the feminine:  Emma, whose last name significantly enough is “Swan” J! — (See my comments on the symbol of the swan in “The Black Swan:  A Three Part Psychological Analysis of the Film”.)  Emma and her “good mother,” Snow White/Mary Margaret Blanchard, are on the positive side of the equation, while the Queen/Regina is on the negative side of the equation.  But our situation is even more complicated than that, because as “Once Upon a Time” tells us, there is also a split in the masculine between the Old King and the new Prince.  Indeed, everyone in “Storybrooke” seems to be split, even Mr. Gold/Rumplestiltskin, the Mephistophelean figure who represents the archetype of choice.  Choice means awareness of two opposites.  We are of two minds collectively and individually.  At least we are perhaps becoming aware of the split.  From week to week, there is usually one character or another who begins to have a slight dawning awareness that something, their “opposite half” is missing, that something has been forgotten, e.g., Mary Blanchard’s dawning realization regarding Prince James/Charming.  This intimation of something that has been lost but might yet be found once again develops through a kind of “dance” between the male and female aspects within the soul of each of us.

In “Once Upon a Time”, all the characters except the protagonist, “Emma”, are trapped in the town of “Storybrooke” where they have forgotten who they are.  Emma, who is representative of both the feminine ego and the more differentiated/developed anima of the male writers of the TV series, is the only one who is not trapped.  She alone, because of her dawning consciousness, can leave and return to Storybrooke.  The rest of the populace is trapped in unconsciousness.  It is as if they had drunk the waters of the River Lethe and forgotten who they are.  Only the young boy, Henry, abandoned by Emma shortly after his birth, realizes what is going on.  He knows who his true mother is.  He is the possessor of the story book with its fairy tales. This story book amounts to a “history book” of the feminine in the psyche — a virtual history book of the soul with its multitude of characters (archetypes) that affect and press themselves upon ego consciousness.

Marcus Tullius Cicero, Rome’s greatest orator and statesman said: “Forgetfulness is the root of all evil.” The motifs of “forgetting who we are” and forgetting our “other half” with whom we were once joined has the psychological meaning of being unconscious of our own inner heights and depths, of not recognizing all aspects of our personality, not being aware of the various unconscious contents of the psyche that need our attention and seek inclusion in a more comprehensive personality.  This type of forgetting is a matter of the soul becoming diminished and shallow.  What is at issue here is the breadth and depth of the soul.  In the matter of soul, the motif of forgetting refers to losing track of what is important, forgetting one’s soul’s purpose and being sidetracked time and again from looking at the soul, from paying attention to the soul — whether because of workaday matters, greed, ambition, pleasure, or out of fear or laziness.  If we look to the history of classical literature, the theme of forgetting is one of The Odyssey's great themes.  The business of the soul is the business of the feminine, whether in a man or in a woman, or in the culture at large.

Psychologically speaking, the young lad, Henry, represents both the youthful inner masculine (animus) of a feminine person and the renewal of consciousness in the man (and the dominant culture which is also masculine).  Henry represents the “new order” of consciousness that is coming into being.  It is this content of the psyche that rattles the cages of the collective consciousness and spurs the female ego to action in the outer world and will not let her give up the quest.   Emma is guided by the young animus who is her son, i.e., psychologically speaking, the child of the ego which has been “adopted” by the evil queen of the underworld.  This spurious “adoption” refers to the “entrapment” — which in fairytales is the equivalent to a case of “bewitchment” — of a youthful masculine content of the feminine soul by the negative mother principle.  Henry is the son of the positive image of the inner feminine (the anima) in a man.  However, his natural state (i.e., the normal activity of the anima as soul guide to the masculine personality) has been usurped by his adoption by the negative image of the inner feminine aligned to collective values.

Looked at from the standpoint of psychology, “bewitchment” refers to a condition where one factor in the psyche (in this case, the new creative idea/new world order that wants to manifest, i.e. Henry) has been hijacked by another content of the psyche (in this case the archetype of the negative mother, the evil queen/Regina, who — along with the Old King — represents the old order) and has been forced into servitude in a field not its own — the unconscious realm (“Storybrooke”) of the negative, devouring mother.  Thus, in “Once Upon a Time”, Henry and all the other characters (except Emma) are “trapped” in the town of “Storybrooke”.  This situation occurs in the life of an individual when there is an unchallenged, rigid bias towards a particular world view.  In our collective situation, that bias is our unquestioned grotesquely hardened intellectual rationalism and overly concrete materialism that will not admit of another creative possibility.  In fairy tales, this hijacking of one psychic factor by another is always represented as a bewitchment by a powerful evil wizard or witch.  For example, in the fairytale of “The Seven Ravens” the bewitched masculine figures are turned into a ravens by a witch.  In other fairytales they may be turned into some other animal.  This means that a content of the psyche that should be humanly related and integrated into the fuller personality can only act on the non-human, animal, instinctual level.

If we look at the thing from the standpoint of feminine psychology, the animus in Emma’s developing consciousness is still quite youthful — perhaps 11 years old.  So the animus is still in the realm of the mother, i.e., immature.  In real life this would show itself in the woman whose creativity has been limited by absent maternal influences and lack of nurturing.  Henry’s activities are limited by his step-mother, Regina, whose name means “Queen” in Latin.  As the mayor of the town of Storybrooke, she represents the leader (reigning dominant conscious standpoint) of the collective.   Thus, psychologically speaking, the power-driven, conniving Regina is the guardian of the dominant collective values within the psyche.  In Storybrooke, she is just slightly more human (on occasion we see some fleeting puzzlement on her face) than her fairytale counterpart, the Evil Queen, who rips out the hearts of her victims and squeezes to dust the hearts she has entombed.  That image is a metaphor for what the power attitude and our rigid intellectual rationalism, materialism, and adamantine concretism does:  it refuses to admit nature and feeling values, it tears out and desiccates our hearts, all feminine values of relatedness, intuition, faith in convergence, and love.  Rationalism cannot admit what it does not understand intellectually:  love and serendipity.  The soul — the heart which was made for those very things — withers. 

Labels: